“@vancityreynolds made some Christmas cookies… ,” Lively captioned a shot of poorly frosted red, green and white snowmen and star-shaped cookies.
“…He’s verrry handsome though,” the actress, who is known for her skills in the kitchen, joked.
Being the playful couple that they are, Reynolds quickly commented on the post, writing, “I wanted to be the first person to bake Christmas cookies using only a hammer.”
WATCH THIS: Food Hack: Make 3 Easy Christmas Treats
More than 1,300 other people have commented on the photo, including model and close friend of the couple Gigi Hadid, who probably made Reynolds feel a little better, writing, “Proud!”
If you’re finding yourself in a similar situation as Reynolds (with Christmas only 3 days away!), we have 31 recipes that will save the day.