What Is It: Starbucks Christmas Tree Frappuccino
Who Tried It: Maggie Malach, PEOPLE Associate Editor, Digital Platforms
Level of Difficulty: 8 (but that was really just logistics)
When I first read the ingredients in Starbucks’ new Christmas Tree Frappuccino — a Peppermint Mocha Creme base, matcha whipped cream, caramel sauce, candied cranberries and a slice of strawberry — I was rightfully wary. Yes, the drink looks like a Christmas tree, but exactly how festive would it be for my taste buds?
Never one to leave a sugar-filled experience to chance, I ran to the nearest Starbucks to place my order. Given the fanfare surrounding the franchise’s themed drinks (#UnicornFrappuccino) I expected the line to be out the door with eager young coffee drinkers, patiently waiting to sip the newest delicacy.
However, while the line was out the door, I appeared to be the only person in Christmas Tree mode. There was a little confusion as to what the drink actually was, and after I showed an employee the ingredient list, I was given something … similar. While my minty drink was good, it lacked the matcha whipped cream, caramel sauce, cranberries and that elusive strawberry slice (not to mention the panache of actually looking like a decorated tree.)
Not to be defeated, I went to the second-nearest Starbucks, where they proudly advertised the specialty drink. Hark! I excitedly placed my order as I sipped my first beverage, which was now serving as an appetizer to the main course: The Christmas Tree Frappuccino. The barista who made it displayed such artistry as she added layer upon layer of festivity to the drink. My coworker and I ooh-ed and ahh-ed at each turn, audibly gasping when she whipped out a single strawberry slice for a garnish.
Want the ultimate dish on the latest celebrity food news, plus exclusive recipes, videos and more? Click here to subscribe to the People Food newsletter.
At first taste, the drink seemed like your standard peppermint mocha fare, but a second sip proved it’s so much more. The whipped cream quickly began to melt, blending with the drink in a way that added a slight hint of green tea. Given all of the different flavors at play (I’m looking at you, candied cranberries), I didn’t know what to expect. But everything melded together in a way that totally worked, even if all of the flavors weren’t standouts.
The Verdict: While presentation counts a lot in this game, it wasn’t enough to send me on another quest for a refill. However, it was totally worth burning about a Christmas Tree Frappuccino’s worth of calories to find the perfect one — for the Instagram.